Back to articles

Present Perfect vs. Past Simple: Differences and Practice

Learn when to use the present perfect or past simple with a hotel dialogue, worked examples, and five practice situations with explained answers.

Available article translations
A receptionist hands a card to a guest at a hotel desk
A receptionist hands a card to a guest at a hotel desk
Contents

At the hotel desk, confirming that you’ve paid and saying when you paid answer two different questions.

Suppose you’ve paid for a hotel booking. You can say I’ve paid for the booking to confirm that it’s paid, or I paid for the booking when you’re talking about a past action, for example when someone asks what you did yesterday. In this lesson, you’ll learn to choose the tense that fits the question and switch between the two tenses in one conversation.

Start by working out what the question is about

  • What happened then? Use the Past Simple for an action in a finished period. I paid yesterday.
  • What’s been done by now? Use the Present Perfect for a result that matters now. I’ve already paid.
  • Has this ever happened up to now? Use the Present Perfect to ask about experience. Have you ever stayed here?

In affirmative sentences, the Present Perfect uses have/has + the past participle, as in she has written. The Past Simple uses the past form, as in she wrote. After did, go back to the base form: Did she write?

How the tenses change in one dialogue

Receptionist: Have you paid for the room yet?

Guest: Yes, I have.

Receptionist: When did you pay?

Guest: I paid yesterday, but I’ve lost the receipt.

First, the receptionist needs to know whether the room is paid for. Then they ask when the payment happened. In the last line, I paid yesterday answers that question, while I’ve lost the receipt explains why the guest can’t show it now.

Two situations that often cause confusion

The time can be clear from the conversation

The question How was your trip? makes it clear that the trip is over. You can answer We stayed near the station without adding yesterday or last week.

Both tenses can appear with “today”

I’ve answered three emails today. You’re giving a running total for today. I answered three emails before lunch today. You’re talking about a finished part of the day.

With a finished time expression such as yesterday, write I sent it yesterday. In conversational American English, you may hear Did you eat yet? where British English typically uses Have you eaten yet? Pay attention to what the speaker means when you choose a tense.

Five situations to practise

Say each line aloud, choosing the tense yourself. First ask what matters to the listener: a present result, experience up to now, or an event in the past.

  1. A colleague is waiting for the file. Tell them it’s already been sent.
  2. Your colleague asks when you sent it. Say you sent it at nine this morning.
  3. You’re choosing a hotel. Ask whether your companion has ever stayed there.
  4. You’re talking about last year’s trip. Ask whether your companion stayed near the station.
  5. At the hotel desk, explain that you can’t find the receipt and that you paid yesterday.

Answers and explanations

  1. I’ve already sent the file. Your colleague needs to know its status now.
  2. I sent it at nine this morning. You give the time the action happened.
  3. Have you ever stayed here? You ask about experience up to now.
  4. Did you stay near the station? The conversation has already established the time: last year’s trip.
  5. I’ve lost the receipt, but I paid yesterday. You don’t have the receipt now, and you know when you paid.

One-minute recap. Think of one thing you’ve done today. First report the result: I’ve booked the tickets. Then answer When did you book them? with one sentence in the Past Simple.